Transmission Cars Guide : Automatic vs Manual

Many of us dream of having a car with all the luxuries and luxuries that help him relax and enjoy the road while he drives, so there was a reason for making a car with an automatic transmission, but since it is a new feature placed in the car, it has raised the price of the car in the sense that it becomes more expensive than a car with a manual transmission So now we will make a comparison between the manual and automatic types.
But before we turn to the comparison between the two types, let us first know what is the transmission and its importance;
Transmission: It is the one who works to transfer the energy produced by the engine of the car to the wheels of the car.
You cannot go anywhere without it, your engine may idle and review, but the car will not move without a transmission, and this is important.

Manual transmission

Also known as a shifter, the driver literally uses a stick to change gears. In older cars it was found on a pillar or dashboard, but in a modern car, the shift lever is almost always installed perpendicular to the center console.

To change gears, the clutch disc located between the engine and the transmission must be released via a third pedal located on the left side of the brake. Release the clutch, select the required gear, and engage the clutch again. From a standstill, engaging the clutch too slowly will cause the disc to wear prematurely, and engaging it too quickly will cause the engine to stall.

Many people take the time to learn how to turn a wand, but it is much simpler than it sounds. In addition, those who can operate a manual transmission can drive any type of vehicle, anywhere in the world.

Three-speed manual transmission shifts were popular in the 1940’s, 1950’s, and 1960’s.
Then engineering departments added gears as an improved technology. Then it’s four decades, then five, and now six. However, some high-end sports cars offer seven speeds.

Converting with a manual transmission is more exciting, more fun and more realistic than driving a car with an automatic transmission, this topic is confirmed by every follower of auto matters.
So, if you want to play football, go to the stadium by yourself is much better than playing with a controller or the Playstation, through the gears it makes you feel like a racing car driver.
Certainly, your left leg may tire and suffer from pain as a result of frequent use of it, especially in traffic jams, but when you rush on an open road, car enthusiasts consider the manual transmission as the most enjoyable option.
Fans of cars with manual transmission consider these cars to be cheaper than automatic and more fuel-efficient as well.

But if this is true that manual transmission cars are cheaper than automatic cars, then it is no longer true that manual transmission is more fuel efficient.

The manual transmission was considered an option when talking about fuel efficiency, because when you reach a place where you have to stop in the event that you are driving a car equipped with a manual transmission, you must choose to select the neutral position in the conveyor, either by shifting or by pressing clutch. If you do not, your vehicle may stop suddenly.

As for the rate of fuel consumption, the regular car is less fuel consumption than the automatic, noting that international car companies have worked over the past years to reduce fuel consumption in automatic cars.

With regard to driving pleasure, lovers of manual cars consider it the best, but it requires high capabilities to control the movement of the car on congested roads and during traffic jams.

back to menu ↑

Automatic transmission gearbox

I don’t know if you know it, but the automatic transmission was considered a luxury, and it was an expensive option on many cars for a long time.

There are two basic types of automatic transmission. The conventional automatic transmission is attached to the engine via a hydraulic torque converter, and the dual automatic transmission adopts clutches. Both can change gears without driver intervention.

The operation is done hydraulically or electronically by monitoring important parameters such as the position of the accelerator pedal, the speed at which the vehicle is moving, and the engine speed.

On many automatic cars, gears can be set manually using the shift lever or paddles attached behind the steering wheel.

An automatic car tends to be softer and more comfortable to drive, especially during pauses and stops.
An automatic installation usually requires less maintenance, although it may vary from model to model.
PFinally, the automatic dual transmission gearbox often shifts gears in just fractions of a second for more performance and efficiency.
A four-speed automatic transmission was the standard in the industry, and a small handful of cars last with only four gears.
However, a six-speed, seven and eight-speed automatic is popular today. For example, Honda is adopting a nine-speed transmission, and Ford and General Motors have jointly developed a 10-speed transmission in the market.
Experts added that the nine-speed automatic transmission significantly contributes to reducing fuel consumption.
This is because the transmission from one ratio to another is done by valves operating with speed-dependent control devices. When a certain speed is reached, the speed-dependent control device disengages the first interlock and connects the second ratio. Thus, in this way, the transmission is automatic, and the torque suitable for the speed is provided.
Unlike the normal transmission, in which the driver interferes himself when (shifting) or shifting the gear from the first to the second to the third to the fourth, and therefore the disengagement process is subject to the whim of the driver, who is often nervous in driving, especially in crowded places that force the driver to stop And slow motion again.
The advanced electronic control systems for automatic transmission, including five or four ratios, in addition to the over drive torque converter, work more efficiently to reduce fuel consumption.

back to menu ↑

Differences between manual and automatic transmission

back to menu ↑

In terms of life span

The process of gradation during transmission from one ratio to another in the automatic transmission extends the life of all mechanical devices in the transmission, due to the accurate automatic gradient process without any error from the driver. That is, without the occurrence of sudden shocks by transmitting a wrong movement from one relative to another, as happens to the manual or normal transmission, where you must gradually move the transmission so that nothing happens wrong with the devices.

back to menu ↑

In terms of regular maintenance

There is no clear complaint that the automatic transmission has registered higher rates of faults than the manual transmission, and all else, it is just an unfounded guess. In fact, the normal transmission needs to change the clutch disc from time to time, and this is completely absent in an automatic transmission.

back to menu ↑

In terms of driving in rough terrain

A car that includes an automatic transmission is better when driving in the desert, and the hobby of driving is spread in rough areas of valleys, plains and sands. This facilitates the use of four-wheel drive cars with automatic transmission, for several reasons, including: saving fuel consumption, comfort in driving, In addition to enjoying the wild scenery.
Unlike cars that operate with a manual transmission, which drives the driver a lot, especially while driving in those areas that require walking at low speeds, which means that the driver is busy switching between ratios! Also, walking on sand with an automatic transmission is better. Where the transition process between the ratios in the automatic transmission is smooth, unlike the normal transmission, which includes shifting and the use of clutch, which leads to the vehicle landing or slowing its acceleration,
Despite the supremacy of cars with automatic transmissions, owners of automatic transmission cars must do regular maintenance of the car’s battery and check on its efficiency as always.
Unlike a car with a manual transmission, one of the advantages of a manual transmission is that it is not related to the efficiency of the battery, and the car can rotate, take off and start by simply pushing it from the back.

back to menu ↑

By price

Cars equipped with a manual transmission are less expensive than those equipped with an automatic transmission. This may be one of the few advantages recorded for the regular transmission.
Now, after that comparison, a question came to my mind, which is…

back to menu ↑

Which transmission is the best manual or automatic ?

The type of transmission you want in your car depends on two important factors: the type of vehicle you have and your driving style.

If you care about peace of mind and relaxation while driving, the automatic transmission is perfect for your needs.

But if your commutes are long and the car does not stop a lot, then a car with a manual transmission is more fun to drive. Note, however, that you may not have a choice because many new cars now offer only one type of transmission.
But in the end, your choice of the type of vehicle, whether manual or automatic, depends on your priorities, work, your budget, your taste and the road that the driver will take.
Therefore, you must specify your priorities when purchasing.
So it is recommended to use manual cars on highways and not crowded roads, while automatic cars are preferred in bad road conditions and traffic congestion, and when you need to stop a lot while driving.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

CAR magazine website | News | Scoops | Review
Compare items
  • Total (0)